Skip to content
Data Arena

A Limited Opening for US-Iran Dialogue, Yet a Quick End to the War Remains Improbable

Damaged civilian areas in Tehran
US-Israeli attacks on Iran have leveled civilian areas of Tehran, upending the lives of its citizens.

US President Donald Trump's dramatic characterization of "very strong talks" with Iran implied the door to negotiations had been swung wide for what he termed "a complete and total resolution of our hostilities in the Middle East."

However, Iran almost immediately rejected that negotiations had commenced – and to date, there are only indications of small openings being created – by a crack.

A key is the same window that was shattered during prior rounds of diplomacy, in last February and in June, by US-backed Israeli strikes on Iran which eradicated the minimal trust that existed.

Sources indicate limited communication between the two chief diplomats from prior discussions – Iran's top diplomat Abbas Araghchi and US envoy Steve Witkoff. But these conversations are characterized as very preliminary.

Moreover, Tehran now regards the Witkoff channel as a deception.

"The remarks of the US president are an element in attempts to reduce energy prices and buy time for the implementation of his military plans," was the response from Iran's foreign ministry.

This is a view echoed by additional analysts as well, who see a US commander-in-chief under mounting pressure to reduce oil prices, boost stocks, and showcase progress in halting this perilous war triggering economic shock globally – including in America.

Additionally, Trump is also seeking the kind of opening which appeared in Venezuela, with an Iranian counterpart of the new interim President Delcy Rodríguez – a powerful but pragmatic leader whom he can attempt to bend to his will.

In the early days of this conflict, he described Venezuela as "an ideal scenario" for Iran.

This betrayed a misunderstanding of the fundamental distinctions between Venezuela and Iran's complex political structure, honed and hardened over nearly five decades to ensure its survival by sidelining moderates and repressing opposition.

Mohammad-Bagher Ghalibaf
Ghalibaf is viewed by Trump as someone who could potentially span the divides between Iran's security and governmental establishments.

However, Trump now says they're dealing with a "high-ranking person" in the Islamic Republic.

The unidentified individual frequently mentioned, after first reports in Israel's media, is Mohammad-Bagher Ghalibaf.

He's held leading positions in the apparatus of Iran, including head of police, commander of the air corps in the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), as well as president of the parliament.

He was unsuccessful four times in bids for the presidency and labeled Iranians who took to the streets nationwide in February calling for change as "adversaries and terrorists."

Yet in Trump's view, Ghalibaf is a powerful figure who could possibly bridge the rifts between Iran's security and political establishments.

Insiders say there have been indirect efforts to try to open a conversation with Ghalibaf, but there's as yet no official or public sign they've produced any result.

For Iran, it's still extremely dangerous, since Israel has been assassinating one senior official after another, including Ali Larijani, the hardline security official who understood the regime inside out. He was seen as a potential go-between if substantive negotiations were ever commenced.

Ghalibaf has also been entrenched among its most unyielding elements, who now control policy. Since Larijani's killing, he's now being viewed with curiosity as a person who might one day do a deal.

"He's the last man standing who's perceived as more ideologically flexible," said one insider with knowledge of the multiple diplomatic efforts. "However even Trump noted if he named him, they'd kill him, and then Israel promptly named him."

"This is the most intriguing channel to watch," commented Ellie Geranmayeh, a senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations.

But it is not evident if there has been any movement along it.

"No side would meet at that high level until the US and Iran are approaching a political breakthrough and a lot of negotiations are needed before they even reach that point," Geranmayeh continued.

So far, Ghalibaf has become a chief critic, taking on Trump's own barrage of comments on social media.

"Our people demand the total and degrading punishment of the attackers," Ghalibaf declared in a post on X on Monday. "No negotiations with America have occurred."

With the two sides wide apart, and at war, and with leading officials like Ghalibaf concentrated on their own security as well as the regime's, a summit would be a daring leap.

For the moment, most diplomacy involves operating the phones. Proposals, several pages long, are being mooted by intermediaries racing to find a way out of this deepening crisis.

On this occasion, new countries are engaging in this age-old crisis, such as Pakistan, Egypt, and Turkey, which have not been on the front lines of the war itself. Their leaders have cultivated close personal relationships with Trump, and they've been actively participating in an broadened forum of Arab-Islamic nations.

Oman, the traditional mediator most trusted by Tehran, also says it's participating in efforts to de-escalate tension and reopen the crucial Strait of Hormuz.

An airport in the UAE
Iran has been attacking many of its Gulf neighbours, including Dubai Airport, in the United Arab Emirates.

However, most Arab Gulf leaders, furious over what they've termed as Iran's "irresponsible" attacks on their countries' infrastructure, are more concentrated on reassessing this relationship. "It will take decades to repair this rupture," one senior official in the Gulf remarked.

Pakistan, whose armed forces and government leaders have cosied up to Trump, offered a way to step back from his risky precipice after the warning to strike Iran's oil infrastructure, by offering to host high-level talks as soon as this weekend.

An interesting sidebar was the recent statement by Iran's new Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei, in which he singled out Pakistan as being dear to his father, the former leader assassinated in the first hours of this war.

Yet there's still no verification of any sort of meeting.

"There are no talks at this juncture," noted Ali Vaez of the International Crisis Group, referring to the messages being passed between Washington and Tehran as attempts "to initiate ceasefire negotiations."

"However I doubt they are anywhere close to establishing enough common ground for a substantive meeting or meaningful talks," he cautioned.

And, as this war grinds on, Iran is making it clear that it wants to exact a significant price. It has issued a list of demands – unacceptable for Washington to accept – including the withdrawal of US bases in the region, to compensation, and firm guarantees against any future aggression.

Demands have also toughened on the other side. Arab Gulf states will now demand that Iran's ballistic missiles need to be part of discussions as well as restrictions over the Strait of Hormuz, which has been weaponised by Iran in this war.

And then there is the profound gulf in perception and confidence, which leads many to be doubtful.

"Trump likely believes this war has granted him extra leverage to get Iran to accept his conditions, and Iran senses it has not only fortified its position but has additional bargaining chips in the Strait of Hormuz," observed Mohammad Ali Shabani, chief of the Amwaj.media website.

In his post announcing the talks, Trump said he was delaying his threat to strike Iran's power plants for five days – meaning all eyes are on his new deadline – Friday, when the markets close.

Written by

Sandra Chapman

Data scientist with over a decade of experience in predictive modeling and AI ethics, passionate about making complex data concepts accessible.

Data Arena

Type to search articles.